A debtor's attempt to have her bankruptcy filing fee waived was ultimately denied by Judge Bucki in Buffalo, after it was revealed the debtor was entitled to a large tax refund when the case was filed. This tax refund was treated as income, at least for the purpose of...
Recent Cases in the Bankruptcy Court Western District of New York
Charges & Cash Advances & charges Just Prior to Filing Provoke Discharge Complaint
If a debtor has recently run up a credit card account, will the bank seek to have its debt excepted from discharge? How much debt and over what sort of time period might cause a bank to file an exception-to-discharge lawsuit in the bankruptcy case? One review of...
Fixtures and the homestead exemption: Grucza
In re Grucza 09-11140 (Decision Sept. 9, 2009, Judge Kaplan): Is a pile of cinder blocks similar to storm windows stored in the garage or more like a not-yet-installed hot tub? Or perhaps like George Washington's statute? Or Cleopatra's Needle? Judge Kaplan wrestled...
Filing of claims in reopened cases
In re J&S Conveyor, Inc. 95-22963 (Decision August 11, 2009; Judge Ninfo, Rochester). Complicated decision in an old, reopened case. The debtor corporation filed Chapter 11 Oct. 27, 1995. Apparently the corporation was the beneficiary of a life insurance policy...
PMSI car loan includes roll-over debt: Peaselee appeal
Peaslee (2nd Circuit Oct. 9, 2009): Peaslee is a Western District of New York Chapter 13 case appealed all the way to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York City, which, in turn, certified the central issue of the case to the New York State Court of Appeals....
Self-employment net income exempt: Dziedzic
In re Dziedzic 08-14061 (Decision March 24, 2009; Judge Bucki, Buffalo): Personal services income exemption for self-employed applies to net income only. Debtor, a self-employed chiropractor, asserted a 90% personal services exemption for services rendered 60 days...
Acceleration of a mortgage does not turn it into a short term mortgage: Maiorino
In re: Maiorino 08-21335 (Decision March 11, 2009; Judge Ninfo) In this case a Chapter 13 debtor attempted to modify a long-term mortgage by paying it off in full within the plan at below-contract rate of interest (See the case note in Laimer, in the 2008 cases.) The...
Exempting life insurance after Wornick decision: MacDonald
In re MacDonald 08-11741 (Decision March 10, 2009; Judge Bucki, Buffalo) Motion by debtors to compel trustee to return life insurance proceeds turned over pursuant to the 2002 decision in Teufel etc. Prior to 2008, Western District of New York courts held that when a...
Successor creditors must prove they own the claim: Doherty
In re: Doherty 06-22278 & Benedetti 07-21620 (Decision February 23, 2009; Judge Ninfo): Proofs of claims were filed in each case by alleged successors to the original creditors. The Trustee objected to the claims, and the Court disallowed them, as the claimant...
Recorded mortgage with misspelled name not a perfected lien: Badagliacca
In re Badagliacca 06-22132; Arnold as Trustee v. Bank of New York AP 08-2032 (Decision February 23, 2009; Judge Ninfo) Mortgage misspelled the debtor's surname on its mortgage document ('Badaglicca' rather than 'Badagliacca'), so that a search of the index of land...